I stayed at every single Disney World resort and ranked them from worst to best

Average room rate: $450 to $800

Level: Deluxe

Inspired by its namesake New York town, this Victorian-style resort embraces the equestrian theme throughout its sprawling property.

Its sheer size leads to a number of issues, like packed pools and crowded bus transportation to parks. Plus, the older property feels a bit dated, and there’s no guarantee that you’ll be housed in one of the newly remodeled rooms.

For a deluxe-level resort, it lacks any standout dining options, and it’s a bit far from the parks. But it does come with the perk of being able to walk to Disney Springs.

Average room rate: $300 t0 $400

Level: Moderate

Disney’s Coronado Springs embraces Spanish and Mexican influences in its design, but it’s not enough to make you forget that this is a functioning convention center.

Given its size, you could easily clock in a mile before ever setting foot in a theme park — especially if you’re interested in walking over to the pool that features a replica 50-foot Mayan pyramid.

The saving grace is the newest addition, Gran Destino Tower, which carries a more upscale feel complete with a rooftop lounge and stunning views.

Average room rate: $600 to $800

Level: Deluxe

You can choose between beachside vibes or nautical sophistication at Disney’s adjacent deluxe resorts, Yacht Club and Beach Club.

The two share most amenities, meaning the big sand-bottom pool — which has a popular slide going through a life-sized shipwreck — can get packed.

For the price, I find the atmosphere to be a bit too polished, and given the number of guests, on-site dining is always in great demand.

There’s a walking path to the BoardWalk, Epcot, and Hollywood Studios, but I’m not sure the location can even justify the price.

Average room rate: $650 to $800

Level: Deluxe

Disney’s Contemporary Resort is perhaps the most recognizable on the property thanks to its unique A-frame shape, which allows the monorail to soar right through the lobby.

It’s a family favorite for those who spend the bulk of their time at Magic Kingdom, which is just a short walk away.

The overall look could use a refresh. There are no distinct design elements aside from a 90-foot mural by Disney legend Mary Blair, the visionary behind classic attractions like It’s a Small World.

Among smaller quick-service locations and lounges, the Contemporary is home to Chef Mickey’s character-dining experience, the new Steakhouse 71 restaurant and lounge, and California Grill — a rooftop restaurant known for its standout sushi and floor-to-ceiling views of Magic Kingdom’s fireworks.

Average room rate: $900 to $1,000

Level: Deluxe

Setting the scene with a live pianist in the lobby, the theme and mood of the Grand Floridian exude utter class.

It’s ideal for families with young kids as it provides easy access to Magic Kingdom via the monorail, boats, or a walking path.

I enjoy the libations at the “Beauty and the Beast”-themed cocktail bar (Enchanted Rose) and the refined dinner at its newly revamped “Mary Poppins Returns”-themed restaurant (Cítricos).

I love visiting the resort during the holidays because of the impressive Christmas display, including a life-size gingerbread house and stunning tree.

Average room rate: $500 to $700

Level: Deluxe

You’ll swear there’s a warm ocean breeze blowing your way in landlocked Orlando when you visit the homey Old Key West Resort.

Well-executed theming, tranquil walking paths, and a standout pool help this resort stand out.

At Olivia’s Cafe, you’ll even spy a photo wall of families who return to stay year after year. I’m also a fan of the laid-back vibes at Gurgling Suitcase Libations, which serves the resort’s signature Turtle Krawl cocktail.

But for being a deluxe resort, it lacks a proper bar and restaurant.

Average room rate: $600 to $700

Level: Moderate

The Cabins at Disney’s Fort Wilderness Resort is where camping meets modern amenities.

The internal bus system can be complicated, but there’s no need to deal with it when you can cruise around on your own private golf cart.

Special touches, like campfire sing-a-longs and movies under the stars make this a favorite. This is also the home of Tri-Circle-D Ranch which allows guests to meet the horses who appear with characters around the theme parks.

Interesting on-site dining options, like one of the longest-running dinner shows, The Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue, make this the total package.

Average room rate: $300 to $400

Level: Deluxe

Although Marriott’s Swan & Dolphin Resorts are not operated by Disney, they’ve been official on-property resorts since opening in 1990.

Ideally located between Epcot and Hollywood Studios, the two resorts are adjoined by an incredible tropical oasis, complete with a 3-acre grotto pool, slide, and lively pool bar.

On-site dining is plentiful, including celebrity ventures from Todd English, chain spots like Shula’s Steakhouse and Trattoria Il Mulino, and even a karaoke bar.

I consider this an absolute steal as it’s priced similarly to moderate-level resorts while offering the level of amenities and services expected from a deluxe. 

Average room rate: $800 to $1,000

Level: Deluxe

I reach peak vacation mode every time I set foot in Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort.

Dating back to Disney World’s opening in 1971, the resort exudes paradise through tropical-inspired décor, ambiance, and dining.

In addition to newly renovated rooms, you also have a vast number of transportation options, including the monorail, boats, walking paths, and buses.

I love sipping on a tropical cocktail from Trader Sam’s Grog Grotto on the sandy beaches of the Seven Seas Lagoon while watching Magic Kingdom’s fireworks just across the water.

You’ll also find some cult-favorite Disney foods, like Dole Whip and Tonga Toast.

Note: These rates were accurate at the time of publication but are subject to change.

This story was originally published in June 2022 and most recently updated on September 5, 2024.