Elon Musk is ready to make his biggest pitch yet that Tesla is more than just a car company

However, what’s critical to note is the timing for Tesla’s robotaxi push. It comes at a tough moment for Elon Inc. For one, Tesla has been unable to escape sales pressure that has hit the wider EV market.

In the first half of the year, Tesla generated $46.8 billion in revenue, down from $48.3 billion in the same period last year. While Tesla posted a 6.4% year-on-year jump in deliveries for its third quarter, its value remains over $600 billion short of the $1.2 trillion peak it hit in November 2021.

Caspar Rawles, chief data officer at Benchmark Mineral Intelligence, an industry firm focused on market prices and supply chain data for EVs, expects EV growth to continue long-term but acknowledges that recent macroeconomic headwinds have led to a slowdown.

“You’ve seen higher interest rates, inflation, all kinds of hangovers from the pandemic,” Rawles told BI. “EV sales have grown far more quickly than traditional internal combustion engine vehicles; they’re just not growing as quickly as people thought.”

Reactions to Musk’s overall brand have become more visceral as Tesla’s shareholder base has split on his leadership following his controversial transformation of Twitter into X and his endorsement of former President Donald Trump.

“Elon bought Twitter and decided that he was going to become a global leader for the rightwing country of Elonville,” said Ross Gerber, Gerber Kawasaki Wealth and Investment Management CEO and Tesla shareholder.

Gerber told BI that while he believed EVs are a business that can be “wonderfully profitable” — something that made the case strong to invest in Tesla in years prior — he feels far less confident about the robotaxi pivot.

This is largely because Musk will be entering a market where competitors have a headstart. Waymo, owned by Google’s parent company, Alphabet, struck a partnership with Uber last year. BYD, a Chinese EV maker, has also partnered with Uber to bring “autonomous-capable vehicles” to customers globally.

In China, Tesla’s biggest market outside the US, local internet giant Baidu has already deployed a robotaxi fleet called Apollo Go, first launched in Wuhan in 2022. It is aggressively enticing consumers with heavy subsidies that translate to dirt-cheap fares.

“Robotaxis, in theory, could be profitable as long as there’s not a lot of competition,” Gerber told BI. “The problem is that there is, and it’s already on the road.”

Questions also remain over how confident regulators are about the safety of robotaxis. Last year, GM-owned self-driving company Cruise took a reputational hit following crashes involving its vehicles. Incidents like this have a knock-on effect on how the wider autonomous vehicle space is perceived, including Tesla’s robotaxis.

That’s especially true because experts think the fully realized version of Musk’s robotaxi ambitions presents technical challenges. Paul Miller, principal analyst at Forrester, said full autonomous driving means “a vehicle should be able to drive itself pretty much anywhere a human driver could, on any type of road, in any weather conditions.”

“It’s more achievable to allow cars to drive themselves on particular types of road, in known locations, and in specific conditions,” he said ahead of Tesla’s Robotaxi Day.

Clearly, then, Musk has a big story to tell on Thursday. Under the Hollywood lights, he’ll be hoping investors are willing to believe in it as much as he is.